THE LOOP | PART 3 OF 5: LEADERSHIP Your Employees Are Staying. But at What Cost?
What if your organization’s low turnover rate is actually a symptom of a leadership problem?
Employees are staying in their jobs, but not necessarily because they are engaged, fulfilled, or committed.
Economic uncertainty, limited career opportunities, and fear of losing financial security are encouraging people to hold on to their current roles. Korn Ferry describes this trend as job hugging. Gartner highlights the problem of regrettable retention: employees remaining in roles despite a mismatch between their capabilities, motivation, and organizational needs.
Staying at your current job for financial security doesn’t automatically mean you’re disengaged or underperforming. Many employees continue to deliver exceptional results.
But low turnover is no longer a reliable indicator of organizational health as it was in the past. And the cost of ignoring this fact may be greater than leaders realize.
The Hidden Cost of Staying
When people are in a role where they feel stuck, disconnected or unable to grow the impact may not be immediately apparent in the retention reports.
Instead, they can surface elsewhere:
- Innovation: People focus far more on protecting their jobs than on experimenting or taking calculated risks.
- Quality: Lower levels of attention, fewer ideas for improvement and less inclination to question the effectiveness of processes.
- Productivity: Slower decision-making and decline in initiative-taking.
These are potential consequences rather than inevitable outcomes for every employee who stays.
Gartner’s November 2026 research identifies regrettable retention as a major productivity killer and recommends that organizations look at performance in the context of intent to stay.
The question is no longer, “How do we retain people?”
It’s ‘How do we create the conditions in which people can thrive, contribute, develop and perform while they’re here?’
This brings us to the third part of The Loop.
In Part 1, we explored organizational responsibility for wellness at work. In Part 2, we examined individual agency when leaving isn’t an option.
Part 3 asks: Who is responsible for creating the conditions that make sustainable performance possible?
The answer goes way beyond the immediate manager.
Leadership Accountability Starts at the Top. But Who Holds the Top Accountable?
We often expect middle managers to engage employees, protect wellbeing, develop talent, and deliver increasingly ambitious business results.
Yet many of the conditions shaping employee experience originate much higher in the organization.
The Board and Investors: Setting the Expectations
Boards and investors influence growth expectations, capital allocation, cost discipline, executive incentives, and strategic priorities. They may simultaneously expect higher returns, faster transformation, improved productivity, and reduced costs.
These objectives are by no means mutually exclusive. The problem arises when the tensions between them are not properly resolved and the pressure goes down through the organization.
Boards have a responsibility to question whether the corporate ambitions are realistic, whether the organization has the capacity to deliver them, and whether the executive incentives are in fact rewarding sustainable performance rather than just short term results.
The CEO: Making the Trade-offs Visible
CEOs translate those expectations into enterprise strategy, priorities, and culture.
They can’t promise aggressive growth, accelerated transformation, lower costs and greater productivity without looking at the resources required and the trade-offs involved. The CEO’s job is not to eliminate all the tensions. It’s to recognise the competing demands, make the decisions and ensure that the executive team are all accountable for those decisions.
EVPs and SVPs: Connecting Ambition with Capacity
Senior executives turn strategy into strategic initiatives, operational reality through budgets, priorities, organizational structures, and resource decisions. This requires challenging competing priorities, enabling cross-functional collaboration, investing in capabilities, and deciding what must stop, change, or wait.
Middle Leadership Translating Strategy into Daily Experience
Middle managers have a massive influence on the employee experience.
Based on Gallup’s research, managers account for around 70% of the variation in team-level engagement.
Yet managers are also under growing pressure. According to Gartner’s April 2026 survey, 47% of managers reported that more was expected of them and that they were working harder than the previous year.
Managers are often asked to protect their teams while delivering targets and managing constraints they did not create. We can’t expect them to absorb the organization’s contradictions forever.
AI Is Widening the Gap Between Ambition and Capacity
AI adds another dimension to this leadership challenge.
Organizations expect AI to increase productivity, reduce cost, reduce headcount, improve decision making and create a competitive advantage.
But implementing AI also requires time, experimentation, new skills, process redesign, and changes in how work gets done.
PwC’s Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey 2026 shows an emerging gap: AI-enabled employees are becoming increasingly agile and adaptive. On the other hand, the underlying organization (the systems, the workflows) is not necessarily keeping up.
The research found that 64% of workers had used AI at work in the previous year, yet organizations are still struggling to get any real value out of that adoption.
The leadership challenge is no longer just about getting people to adopt AI. It’s about ensuring that the way the organization is structured, the capabilities it has and the way it works in general, all evolve with the people.
Otherwise, we risk having people ready to work differently within systems that are not ready to support them.
AI adoption is therefore not just a technology issue. It’s a leadership issue about priorities, capacity, trust and organizational change.
The issue is not just how fast an organization can adopt AI. It’s how thoughtfully the leaders will go on to redesign the work around it.
Ten Leadership Strategies for Sustainable Performance
There is no single solution. But leaders at every level can take meaningful action.
- Measure retention quality, not just turnover. Understand who is staying, why, and whether they are contributing and growing.
- Create alternatives to resignation. Expand internal mobility, reskilling, project assignments, and opportunities to redesign roles.
- Build psychological safety. Encourage employees to raise concerns, challenge assumptions, and share ideas without fear of negative consequences.
- Balance empathy with accountability. Understand individual circumstances while maintaining clear expectations and performance standards.
- Turn employee feedback into decisions. Identify what can be resolved locally and what requires structural change or executive intervention.
- Align ambition with capacity. Every new priority should be accompanied by a discussion about resources, trade-offs and what can stop you. Boards, CEOs and the executive team have to be very aware of the consequences of having competing demands.
- Reward the right leadership behaviors. Align your incentives, promotions and recognition with sustainable performance rather than performance achieved through persistent overload.
- Hold the senior leaders accountable for how the results are achieved. Assess business performance in line with leadership effectiveness, talent development, succession, and health of organizational.
- Make talent mobility an enterprise responsibility. Challenge talent hoarding and remove barriers that prevent employees from exploring opportunities across the organization.
- Equip the middle managers to lead. Provide strategic clarity, decision-making authority, development, and channels to escalate systemic challenges.
Three Questions for Monday Morning
Before introducing another initiative, setting another target, or asking your team to do more, consider:
- What am I asking people to deliver and how have I enabled them?
- What am I rewarding, tolerating or reinforcing that is the very opposite of what I say?
- What is one decision I can make this week to remove the friction and create the opportunities for sustainable performance?
Closing the Loop
Leadership responsibility is shared.
Boards set the expectations. The CEO sets the priorities and the trade-offs. The senior executives set the operating conditions. Middle managers then take those decisions and turn them into daily reality. And employees make choices within the conditions they encounter.
When those layers are decoupled, organizations risk confusing retention with commitment, activity with productivity, and, most of all, short-term results with sustainable performance.
The consequences may take time to become visible. But delaying action does not make them disappear.
Perhaps the question every leader should be asking is:
If your employees are staying because they feel they cannot leave, what are you doing to make staying a choice?
Pause • Reflect • Choose
THE LOOP is a five-part series exploring how organizational systems, individual agency, leadership, society, and AI shape the future of work.


